Mailbag #159
/Some people have asked if I'll be taking January off like I did last year. As this existence of this post suggests, the answer is no. Last year I took January off to work on the book for supporters that came out in May. This year I'll be taking June or July off to work on the next book, which comes out in October.
Regarding the trick you mentioned in your last post [Note: It’s a trick where any word the spectator names is predicted in the color they chose.] do you think the color aspect of the prediction adds much to the effect? I can’t decide if it’s overkill or if it’s the tweak that makes it impossible. —SS
My concern would be that it might confuse whatever premise you're trying to establish.
If I asked you to imagine any living person—celebrity, friend, someone from your past, whoever—and then I said, "Also, picture them wearing any type of hat," and then I opened my closet door to reveal your childhood butcher wearing a sombrero... does the sombrero actually add anything? Yes, it technically makes it more impossible. But "more impossible" doesn't necessarily translate into stronger magic if it takes away from the purity of an already strong impossibility.
What I could do in that situation is something like this:
"I want you to think of any type of hat in the world. Focus on the style and the material. Hmmm... I'm not getting it. Do me a favor—I want you to think of any living person whose face you know well and imagine that hat on their head. That should strengthen the image and allow me to pick up on the style of hat."
Now when I open the closet door, someone steps forward with their head down and a sombrero on.
"Ta-da! I knew you'd think of a sombrero!"
Then the person looks up and it's revealed to be the person they were imagining too.
Now the hat is there not because it makes the trick more impossible, but because it adds an element of surprise and showmanship. We let them think it's going to be about the trivial detail, and then blindside them with the personal impossibility.
You could (in theory) do the same with this trick. You focus on the unimportant part and let the word reveal come out of nowhere.
"Last night I took a marker and scribbled on a piece of paper. I want you to see if you can focus on the color of the marker I used."
Later, you reveal your prediction and at first it just looks like you're showing they've accurately guessed a color you "scribbled" with. But as you further unfold the prediction, it's revealed to be a word they randomly thought of earlier. (Maybe you had them create a magic word earlier in the effect. Or maybe as part of the "color-focusing" bit you had them imagine any object and then think of it in a color it doesn't normally come in, and it’s that object that’s written on the paper. Either way, you make it seem like your focus is always on the color they're coming up with. This word or object is just tangential to the procedure.)
I don't know if this would work with the procedure from Pigmento, but that's generally how I would approach these things. Get them focusing on the smaller aspect, then hit them with the larger impossibility when they're not braced for it. It should feel like it comes totally out of the blue and completely overwhelm them—as opposed to focusing on the word and then saying, "It's also in the color you named," which feels completely superfluous.
Pigmento may actually use the approach I mentioned here. I have no clue because there's no demo of the effect.
I figure this might be a “it depends” or you have some general heuristics on this.
When you have something pre planned to perform, is there a time during a gathering/social interaction you try to hit to transition to this.
Thinking of a small gathering of people would transitioning to it earlier in the evening vs towards the end when it’s the last “thing” for the evening? —ZA
For most tricks, I don't think it really matters. But when I have something really immersive and strong, I tend to want to put it towards the end of the gathering or meet-up.
Here's why:
It provides a sort of climax to the evening. Structurally, it feels right.
It allows more time to build anticipation. "Oh, a little later there's something I need to show you. Don't let me forget." That little seed of curiosity gets to germinate while you're just hanging out normally.
Rushing into the performance early on can feel a little desperate. Like you showed up for the trick rather than the people.
A really immersive effect has almost a dreamlike quality to it. When you do it at the end of the night, you can leave people in that state when they go. They walk out the door still inside the experience. This is why I often have people text me after hanging out: "Okay, I'm still freaked out by..." or "I can't stop thinking about..." Whereas if you do it in the middle of the interaction, they need to snap out of the reverie just to get on with normal human interaction. The spell breaks because it has to.
Again, this is only something I think about when I'm doing something very strong—something I know is going to leave them a little rattled.