Great Minds
/Here’s an idea from supporter Sam W. It’s a simple, propless effect (other than your phone). It’s perhaps higher on the fun factor than the amazement factor, but it’s relatively strong, especially for an anytime, spur-of-the-moment type of effect. Here’s how it played out for me last weekend.
Imagine
At one of the cafes I typically go to, there was an obvious first date happening at a table near my friend and me. This happens a lot. It’s a go-to spot for people in my area who met online.
The guy was going on and on about his morning routine and cold plunges. As if that was attractive. He was being too loud for us to do any work, but at the same time, we felt odd just sitting there listening to their conversation.
So my friend Kelly started asking me random questions like we were on a first date. “Did you have any pets growing up?” “What was the first concert you went to?”
At one point, I asked her, “Do you think coincidences are just random, or do you think they have some kind of special meaning?”
“They just happen,” she said. “I don’t put any special meaning on them.”
“Me neither!” I said. “What a coincidence. We’re so well matched. What’s your favorite color?”
“Green,” she said.
“Me too! Frickin’… like… grass, you know? What else? Uhm… frogs! Green is so good. So, so good. It’s kinda freaking me out how similar we are.”
“Wait,” I said. “On the count of three, name your favorite animal. Ready? Okay. 1, 2, 3.”
“Turtles,” she said.
“Turtles!” I blurted out, an obvious second too late. “Crazy. Hmm… okay, what’s your favorite number, 1–100?”
“62.”
“Me too. That’s crazy. 62 is the best. Other people don’t get it, but we do, because we’re so similar.” I looked at her face and paused. “I know it doesn’t seem likely, but it’s true. Oh, actually….”
I took out my phone and went to my Notes app.
“Just the other day, I was ranking all the numbers.”
I opened up a note called Number Thoughts. Next to each number were my “thoughts” on that number.
Sucks.
Good. Not great.
Pretty mixed feelings on this one.
Scrolling down to number 62, it said:
The absolute best. So sick.
She took the phone from me and scrolled through the other numbers to see that it really was the only one I unequivocally liked.
Method
You already know.
Here is a list of 99 number “reviews.”
Good. Not great.
Sucks.
Too showy.
Feels a bit offensive.
Can't be trusted.
Pretty forgettable.
Not my favorite.
Trying too hard.
Just okay.
We've had issues.
Kind of annoying.
A little pretentious.
Nothing special.
Could be worse.
Feels outdated.
Too predictable.
Bad attitude.
Not particularly interesting.
Slightly irritating.
Has a bad vibe.
Unnecessarily complicated.
I used to defend this one.
A bit dull.
Not terrible.
Seems fake.
Hard to take seriously.
Pretty uninspired.
Doesn't do much for me.
A little embarrassing.
Thinks it's better than 47.
Too obvious.
Feels cheap.
Mildly unpleasant.
Weirdly aggressive.
Completely unappealing.
It's fine, I guess.
Seems unnecessary.
A little obnoxious.
Bland.
Hasn't aged well.
Kind of depressing.
More trouble than it's worth.
Too self-important.
Nothing to get excited about.
Feels a little desperate.
I gave it a chance.
Not worth the effort.
Slightly creepy.
Pretty mediocre.
Sexy, but in a cheap kind of way.
A bit childish.
Hard to defend.
Strangely off-putting.
Seems like it would be rude to a waiter.
Not particularly charming.
Too much going on.
A little boring.
Leaves a bad impression.
Almost good.
Feels forced.
Trying to be mysterious.
Borderline ridiculous.
Just doesn't work.
Not awful, but close.
I have my reasons.
Feels vaguely dishonest.
Mildly disappointing.
A little smug.
Seems like a bad idea.
Pretty underwhelming.
Not especially likable.
More annoying than interesting.
Feels a bit lazy.
Weird for no reason.
It's tolerable.
A little too proud of itself.
Not welcome in my home.
Has an unpleasant quality.
Kind of a letdown.
Too pleased with itself.
Missing something.
Slightly unsettling.
Not as clever as it thinks.
Pretty pointless.
A bit much.
Unnecessarily flashy.
We've grown apart.
Feels like a mistake.
Barely acceptable.
Not particularly memorable.
A little too cute.
Has the wrong energy.
Racist.
Something about it bothers me.
Not my thing.
A little suspect.
Fine in small doses.
I know things about this one.
Wouldn't recommend it.
And here is Sam’s original email. The idea here is pretty complete. I didn’t much at all to it.
I wanted to share an idea I was playing with a few years ago which I never really ran with.
But it is kinda similar to the Phantom Hit Technique but a tad different.
It started with that hack line “do you believe in coincidences… me too!!!”
I was wondering if I could actually turn that into something.
So if they said yes, I’d say “me too! Wait what’s your favourite colour…. Me too! Oh! Do you have a favourite number below 100? Me too!”
And then I’d open up my list of numbers. Each number would have a review next to it with my feelings for that number. All negative words except the one they chose which said “my absolute favouritist number ever!”
Just DFB…
My idea being that nobody really believes any of those three coincidences. But that in the best case the last phase somehow acts as proof of all three and worst case it just acts of proof for itself and the other phases remain seen as a joke.
If they said they didn’t believe in coincidence then I’d say “me neither” and then still do the other phases. I like the idea of apparently creating a couple of coincidences that neither of us believe in.
I also really like having a list of numbers with my review of how much I like each number with weird comments for each “too showy”, “feels a bit offensive”. And I think the people who know me well wouldn’t be at all surprised if that was something I spent an evening deciding.
The real joke in this email is me considering the both believing in coincidences as a “phase” 😂