Mailbag #188

Do you ever worry having items examined ends up turning the experience into a puzzle? —MS

Hmmm. You’re the third person who has brought this up to me in the past month. I’m not sure where this idea is coming from, because I think it’s exactly backward. Examination is often what turns a trick into magic.

Especially in 2026.

In 1880, if you changed a red deck to a blue deck, people might have immediately appreciated the impossibility of what they’d just seen. They wouldn't necessarily need to examine anything.

When I started performing in the ’90s, a color-changing deck would get a moment of stunned silence, followed by something like, “Wait, do those change color with heat or something?”

In 2026, people have even more potential explanations to reach for. Heat-sensitive ink, e-paper, some sort of special optical coating, or who knows what. The puzzle at that point isn’t how could that possibly happen? It’s which of these methods did he use?

Handing them the deck and letting them see that it’s just a normal pack of cards isn’t turning the experience into a puzzle. It’s eliminating the puzzle. You’re taking away the explanations they might otherwise settle on and allowing them to fully appreciate the impossibility of what they’ve seen.

And this goes for almost everything.

A hundred years ago, if you showed someone a coin, they probably assumed it was just a coin. Today, it’s perfectly reasonable for someone to suspect a specially engineered gimmick. Allowing them to examine it isn’t encouraging them to think about methods. It’s eliminating a whole category of methods from consideration.


The new book is incredible. I’m hooked. […] Because of your 18 months book publishing cycle, you won’t be releasing your next one until 2028. Does 2027 hold any planned trick releases or anything? —HW

No tricks, I don’t think. But there’s a good chance I’ll be doing a 10-year anniversary hardcover collection of just the tricks from JAMM magazine, rewritten, updated where needed, and properly illustrated.

I won’t just be reprinting the magazine pages in book form. It will be a 6 × 9 clothbound book, so it fits in with everything else I’ve released.

I’ll send out an email early next year to gauge supporters’ interest in the project and then decide whether to commit to it.


Thanks for turning me on to Bannon’s Substack [From Keepers 11]. I’m loving your approach to Paint It Blank. He’s posted a lot of false cuts recently, and I was curious if you’ve adopted any of them. —SB

The only area where my interests don’t align with Bannon’s is when it comes to false cuts. I have very little interest in them. Any complicated in-the-hands false cut feels like a step backwards to me from a simple, straight cut in the hands.

That said, I do like the Double Double Dutch Cut (which is also taught on his new download on false cuts) as a replacement for the Jay Ose Cut. Cutting three packets (as in Ose) is already more than people normally do when cutting a pack on the table. So I think it makes sense to expand that to six packets, as John does here. That way, you’re doing something clearly more complicated than the standard two-packet cut. And not just one packet more complicated.

Also, the JB Transfer Cut is a much better way of getting a card or small group of cards from the top to the bottom compared to the swing cut/double undercut combo. But it needs a table.


From personal experience—as someone who has had Pass the Salt since Magic Live—yes, people try to taste the salt. Maybe 20%. The more amazed they are by the trick the more likely they are to lick a finger and dip it in the “salt.” Maybe not if you’re performing for magicians, but real people do. —JR

One of the unfortunate things about magic is that the stronger the trick is, and the more invested the spectator is, the more likely they are to want to examine the end result. Not because they weren't fooled, but because they were.

This is especially true of very straightforward tricks. If I simply change a copper coin into a silver coin, with no other elements to the trick, then all their attention is going to be on that coin. They’re going to want to examine it, make sure it’s really silver, and make sure I don’t switch it.

This trick is super straightforward. It’s a trick about salt and pepper changing places. So of course that’s where people’s focus is going to be. And the one thing that distinguishes salt from a bunch of other white granules is its taste. If someone is dubious, you can see why they’d want to taste it. If someone is credulous, you can also see why they’d want to taste it.

I think Madison Hagler offered the best way to discourage this in his review. If someone goes to taste the salt, he suggests saying, “I wouldn’t do that. That was just in my sweaty hand.”

This is an objection based on the premise of the trick. That the salt they’re holding was just in your hand a moment ago.

Or you could say, “Yeah, you can taste it, but I wouldn’t. Something about the transposition process strips things of their essential properties. The salt loses its saltiness. The pepper…” Taste the pepper in your hand. “Yeah, nothing. Kinda gross, actually. That’s why most magicians stopped doing these transpositions with people back in the late 1800s. They kept ending up as empty, soulless husks.”